
2009 Chevrolet Corvette LT4

2009 Cadillac XLR Platinum
With summer approaching, we’ve decided to put two of our favorite convertibles head-to-head. Presenting the 2009 Cadillac XLR Platinum vs 2009 Chevrolet Corvette LT4:
Price:
No contest here. The Corvette, at $63,270 is over $20K cheaper than the $86,215 priced Cadillac.
Fuel Economy:
We’re calling it a wash. The Caddy, rated at 15/24mpg falls just shy of the Chevy’s 16/26mpg – in real life, the difference is negligible.
Engine:
Dang, this is starting to seem one sided. The Cadillac XLR’s 4.6L V8 produces a solid 320hp@6400rpm, alas, it’s no match for the Chevy’s 6.2L V8 producing 430hp@5900rpm.
Creature Comforts:
The Chevy lacks a navigation system, electronic parking aid, power lumbar support, and other features we’ve grown accustomed to in +$50K cars. The Cadillac has a noticeable edge here.
Performance:
As much as we’d like to say the XLR was on par, we cannot tell a lie. The Corvette is a beast, packed with raw power and far superior handling.
Conclusion:
It pains us to say it, but the Corvette LT4 is the better choice in almost every regard. But we’ve got a challenger in mind that might make the Corvette LT4 go home and cry to mama. Stay tuned for a LT4 vs CTS-V showdown.




